Prep the baking sheet: Line a cookie sheet with parchment paper. This step is essential, especially when you need to move the coated pretzels before they are fully dry.
Sort the pretzels: Separate the Jacks from the Bats into two distinct piles.
Melt the black candy: Place the black candy melts into a melting pot with a little coconut oil. Allow them to melt, stirring occasionally until smooth.
Dip the bats: Dip the bat pretzels into the melted black candy, fully coating each one.
Add the eyes: Place the coated bats onto the parchment paper. Before the chocolate sets, gently press two edible eyes onto each bat, then allow them to dry completely.
Melt the orange candy: Place the orange candy melts into a clean melting pot with coconut oil. Heat and stir occasionally until melted and smooth.
Dip the jacks: Dip the Jack O’Lantern pretzels into the orange melted candy until fully coated, then place them on the parchment paper to dry.
Add green stems (optional): Place the green candy melts into a clean melting pot with coconut oil and stir until smooth. Using a toothpick, paint the stem of each Jack O’Lantern pretzel green. (Note: While optional, adding green to the stems gives them a great extra pop!)
Allow to dry: Allow everything to dry completely and enjoy!